'Doctor Who': Ranking the Christmas specialsAdd to Favorites | Doctor Who
"Doctor Who's" Christmas special is only hours away from airing, so there's no better time to take a look back at the holiday episodes that have come before. "The Time of the Doctor" is sure to earn a place high on this list as fans say goodbye to Matt Smith, but there are many other emotionally charged specials to reflect on as well.
Before tonight's premiere, here's our take on the past seven years of "Doctor Who" Christmas specials, ranked from best to worst:
'The End of Time'
This is a given. David Tennant's send-off was the perfect goodbye to his Doctor, and his final words -- "I don't want to go" -- still make fans emotional to this day. Add that to the fact that the two-parter took viewers to Gallifrey, and this is the best Christmas special yet.
'A Christmas Carol'
Smith's first Christmas special is also his best to date. The episode had then-companions Amy and Rory largely absent as the Doctor helped this episode's Scrooge, Michael Gambon's Kazran Sardick, resolve his lifetime of crotchetiness. Like all of "Doctor Who's" best storylines, the underlying romance was beautiful and tragic, and "A Christmas Carol" was a lovely pause in Smith's mystery-heavy story arcs.
'Voyage of the Damned'
If only Kylie Minogue could have been the Doctor's companion for more than one episode. The Doctor's loneliness shines through as he travels on the space version of the Titanic, and this kooky episode showcases everything that "Doctor Who" does best. Add that to the heartbreaking end and the fantastic chemistry between Minogue and Tennant, and this is one of the show's best episodes.
'The Christmas Invasion'
The first Christmas special of new "Who" is loved for being just that. Sure, there's the killer Christmas tree, and Tennant is asleep for a good portion of the episode, and the special effects weren't at their best, but come on! The introduction of Tennant will always be a fan-favorite.
'The Runaway Bride'
It's worth noting that Zap2it's resident "Doctor Who" expert Chris Hayner would have had this special much farther down the list. But for fans of Donna Noble (especially Doctor Donna), "The Runaway Bride" has a special place of honor for introducing her character. While she transforms into a much more interesting companion farther into Series 4, Catherine Tate provides a nice contrast to the romantic relationship between the Doctor and Rose and the one-sided relationship to come after between him and Martha Jones.
The second introduction to Clara Oswald was hardly as good as "Asylum of the Daleks," but "The Snowmen" showed off her spunk and clever personality more than its predecessor. Add that to the fact Vastra, Jenny Flint and Strax are added as allies and that the Great Intelligence is first introduced, and it's definitely not the worst special.
'The Next Doctor'
As much as we love David Morrissey, his run as Jackson Lake was a bit bland. The episode gets points for its use of Cybermen, and for continuing the discussion of the Doctor's feelings of loneliness. But all in all, meh.
'The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe'
"The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe" was a fun twist on "The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe" and had a happy resolution, but it was hardly one of "Doctor Who's" best specials. The acid rain and wood creatures were some of the zaniest and anticlimactic of "Doctor Who's" storylines, but at least the final scene where the Doctor join Amy and Rory for Christmas is an emotional gut punch.