DVD Review: 'Because I Said So'
It's like the Mother's Day equivalent of a lump of coal at Christmas
Actually, I take that back. If you want to let your mother know that she's a dinosaur in the modern world, a meddling busybody who confuses smothering with love and that the idea of her having sex at her age freaks you out, then by all means, go grab a copy of "Because I Said So," which hits stores on Tuesday (May 8).
Directed by Michael Lehmann, who has long since exhausted whatever good faith he earned for directing "Heathers," "Because I Said So" stars Diane Keaton as Daphne, the shrill harpy of a mother to three beautiful daughters (Mandy Moore, Lauren Graham and Piper Perabo). Two of the daughters have husbands (who were almost completely edited out of the movie), so Daphne decides to go online in a quest to pimp out her youngest, who you know is unlucky in love because she lives alone with her fish and her unblinking answering machine. Thanks to her mother's manipulations (it turns out that she just needs to get laid herself), the daughter faces that eternal cinematic dilemma because the nice, artistic man (Gabriel Macht) that she's perfect with and the successful, richer man (Tom Everett Scott) that her mom prefers. Who will she possibly choose?!?
The script by Jessie Nelson and Karen Leigh Hopkins misses very few cliches (Do the women all sing together? Twice!), but fails to make its main characters at all distinctive, which forces Keaton to over-act wildly. The only one of these women who isn't insufferable is Lauren Graham, which has absolutely nothing to do with how the character is written and absolutely everything to do with the fact that she's played by Lauren Graham. All four leads are routinely upstaged by elaborately decorated wedding cakes and only Lehmann knows how he was able to make a scene featuring Moore, Graham and Perabo in underwear so very, very unsexy.
Lehmann also has coached Macht and Scott to the blandest performances of their careers and since this is Gabriel Macht and Tom Everett Scott we're talking about, that's saying a lot.
Not-so-surprisingly, the extra features on the "Because I Said So" DVD fail to elevate the package. How scarce are actual features? Well, a one-minute commercial for iVillage is categorized as a "bonus," as is an excruciating video for "World Spins Madly On" by The Weepies, which consists mostly of shots from the movie playing out in slo-mo.
Because the iVillage commercial wasn't enough cross-promotion, the behind-the-scenes making-of featurette is prominently sponsored by VW. In a brisk seven minutes, the featurette covers the usual ground -- everybody's adoration of Keaton, hiring a male director to capture this all-female world and the ways in which the cast bonded (eBay). Although it's only six minutes, the "Designing a 'Wilder' World" featurette goes into more depth, touching on the movie's costumes, its use of Los Angeles and those cakes, which were designed the Cake Divas, who are more deserving of credit than anybody else involved with the movie.
Fall TV
What's new, what's coming back and what to watch.
Emmy Awards
Find everything you need to know about the 2007 Primetime Emmy Awards.
Pick your favorite channels
Customize our TV listings to show only the channels you care about.
Get Zap2it delivered
Sign up for our new daily e-mail newsletter so you'll always know what to watch and where to watch it.
Daily Blog
Contests and Giveaways
RSS Feeds
-
Zap2it.com offers several content feeds you can use in RSS news readers. Click on the feeds you're interested in for instructions on adding them to My Yahoo!, Newsgator, Bloglines, and other readers.

TV and Movies 
TV news 
Movie news 
From Inside the Box 
It Happened Last Night 
Celebrity News 
Zap2it's Guide to 'American Idol' 
Zap2it's Guide to 'Lost' 
Zap2it's Guide to 'Gossip Girl' 
Misfits of Sci-Fi





