The Dish Rag

'Fame'

By Michael Sragow, Baltimore Sun | September 24, 2009
'Fame'
'Fame'
Related content
Discuss this story now
The classes in "Fame" include acting, singing and dancing. What the movie really needed is a class in screenwriting. This film has premises -- the schoolrooms, stages and cafeteria of the Professional Performing Arts School in Hell's Kitchen, New York -- but no premise. It simply plops a handful of aspiring entertainers and artists and a few teachers in front of the camera and samples their lives and work from audition day to graduation. And I do mean "samples": it's as if every bit of potential talent or conflict has been put through a digital synthesizer.

The youthful wannabes aren't full-blooded enough to be called characters. They're melodramatic set-ups, like the pianist with the secret socko voice and the parents who just want her to play classical, or the Iowa ballet dancer who may not be strong enough to partner even willowy ballerinas. The only unpredictable thing about this movie is the all-encompassing totality of its banality.

I know everything old can be new again, but this film must be targeting teenagers who've never seen a music video.

The singers fare better than the dancers: at least a couple of vocalists get to deliver entire numbers simply, from beginning to end. The first-time director, Kevin Tancharoen, a former dancer himself, subjects most of his performers to the kind of choreography and editing that reduce even thrilling leaps or tap moves to design elements or show-off feats. (There's more fun to be had in the "Stomp"-meets-Busby Berkeley trickery of the new Campbell's healthy soup commercials.)

Fans of the desperately crowd-pleasing 1980 "Fame," hoping for an updated shot of teenage angst and uplift or a nostalgic second look at "the 'Fame' school" (New York's High School for Performing Arts, predecessor of the Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School of Music & Art and the Performing Arts), must settle for a glimpse of original "Fame" star Debbie Allen as the principal.

With figures like the naiive, over-achieving pretty girl who doesn't know when a couch is a casting couch, or the super dancer who turns out to have a history of depression and a taste for exciting boyfriends, this movie stumbles even when it "just goes through the paces."

At least a couple of the actors playing teachers bring occasional whiffs of actual wisdom into the movie, especially Charles S. Dutton as the acting teacher and Bebe Neuwirth as the dance instructor. And Kelsey Grammer exploits his talent for kindhearted crust as the classical-music guru. But just when you start musing that these characters could have stories more fascinating than those of their youthful charges, you're hit with the mini-bathos of Megan Mullally as a singing coach who could have been a musical-comedy contender.

"Fame" has today's usual gritty form of slick to it, but in every other way it's an Amateur Hour and a half.

haydenpanettiere2_heroes_140

Greatest TV Character Poll

Vote for your favorite characters.


familyguy_140

Emmy Nominees List & Gallery

Find everything you need to know about the 2009 Primetime Emmy Awards.


oliviamunn_140

Comic-Con 2009

Get all the latest Comic-Con news and pictures.


joshholloway_lost_s5_140

Get Zap2it Daily News Alerts & Updates

Sign up for our new daily e-mail newsletter so you'll always know what to watch and where to watch it.


chevychase_community_140

Fall TV Preview

What's new, what's coming back and what to watch.


jasonstackhouse_trueblood_140

Pick your favorite channels

Customize our TV listings to show only the channels you care about.

Find it fast

couples_retreat_300x125
 

Movie Showtimes

More photos added from the Vancouver set of the "Twilight" sequel.