Now in Theaters
Review: 'School for Scoundrels'
Loosely based on a 1960 British comedy, this is a modest education-of-a-punching-bag entertainment with a kind of breezily rude compatibility _ a hallmark of sorts for both co-writer/director Todd Phillips ("Road Trip," "Starsky & Hutch") and the wonderful actor assigned to play the self-help instructor from hell, Billy Bob Thornton.
Last year audiences responded merrily to a similar comic set-up, in which the adventures of Steve Carell's hapless sexual neophyte led to sparkling, incisive relationship humor in "The 40 Year-Old Virgin," but this movie's intentions are more safely in the region of: laugh here, laugh here, fist pump when Heder gets his revenge on Thornton's sinisterly competitive Dr. P, then smile when he gets the girl (Jacinda Barrett, as the neighbor crush). That's not to say there aren't pleasures when a formula works. What's almost refreshing about Phillips' approach to comedy -- there's a reason he made a movie called "Old School" _ is that he and co-writer Scot Armstrong like the classically unfettered fun of a silly bit played to the hilt. For example, Thornton's mealy-mouthed charges getting a quick lesson in the cruelty of paintball is undeniably funny, as is the cross-cutting montage showing Heder and classmates in their everyday lives working up the stones to pick insanely self-destructive fights with bullies and thugs.
Needless to say, personality breakdown is inevitably more amusing than the confidence-building a happy ending requires, which means Thornton's villainous drill sergeant is the film's real laugh weapon. Heder's admittedly unique Ichabod Crane shtick may make him Hollywood's favorite new point-and-laugh target, but it's the "Sling Blade" actor's emergence in recent years as a comedy star, playing hilariously brittle, insult-wielding satyrs in sardonic corkers such as "Bad Santa" and "The Bad News Bears" that's become the real master seminar in scoundrel-hood. In fact, that's arguably the biggest problem with the taste-of-his-own-medicine story line: in a Heder/Thornton matchup, you're not altogether sure you want to see teach lose.