17 of 32
How I Met Your Mother - The Slutty Pumpkin
In their own take on the Charlie Brown special, "How I Met Your Mother" has Ted waiting every year at the rooftop party on Halloween for the dream girl whose number he lost years ago. She was dressed as a Slutty Pumpkin and so that she'll recognize him, he always dons his "Hanging Chad" costume. But in 2011, the Slutty Pumpkin finally returned -- played by Katie Holmes. Good grief.
Oct. 2, 2012