2 of 14
Cannon fodder: Kelly Monaco
Partner: Val Chmerkovskiy
Copyright © 2009, The Baltimore Sun
Sep. 20, 2012
"Star" cred: Actress, soap star
Original season finish: Season 1, 1st (sort of)
She won Season 1, when the show wasn't the runaway hit it is now. And even that win was disputed; so much so that they aired a run-off special between her and the runner-up.