7 of 30
'Criminal Minds' (2007)
The plot: In "The Big Game," a troubled young man believes he's the Archangel Raphael with a mission to rid the world of sinners. / How many watched: 26.3 million / Touchdown or fumble: Fumble. Having James Van Der Beek as a guest star/psycho killer does not a classic episode make. "Criminal Minds" mustered 11.5 million less viewers than "Grey's Anatomy" the previous year.