21 of 26
'Extreme Makeover: Home Edition' (ABC)
Viewers: 5.27 million
Rank: 69th in viewers, 89th in 18-49 (1.2)
Fun fact: Though "EM:HE" was officially canceled last season, ABC revived it for a brief run this fall after "Dancing With the Stars" ended. The numbers haven't made anyone reconsider the cancellation.