: 2002 Premise
: Both shows focused on 30-something dudes whose lives were in a rut. Due to freak accidents involving either being "zapped" ("Do Over," top) or struck by lightning ("That Was Then," bottom) each fellow gets to start over in his adolescence (1981 for "Do Over" and 1988 for "That Was Then").
: Neither show made it out of Season 1, but "Do Over" wins because it aired 11 episodes to "That Was Then's" two and it also starred "Gossip Girl's" Penn Badgley as the young version of the main character. -- Andrea Reiher, Zap2it