1 of 18
Tamyra Gray, Season 1
Copyright © 2009, The Los Angeles Times
Apr. 12, 2012
America experienced its first “"Idol"” shocker back in Season 1 when vocal stunner Tamyra Gray was voted off the show before the magenta-haired Nikki McKibbin. Questions about whether there was a problem with the telephone lines were raised, and some swore to never watch the show again.