Midseason report card: Which new Fall 2012 TV series are making the grade?

(ABC)
18 of 19

'666 Park Avenue'

What we said then: "While the atmosphere sets up feelings that something scary is going to happen, the actual scares are not there."

What we say now: Well, "666 Park" has been axed by ABC, though it will continue airing until its initial 13-episode order has played out. Still, we really ended up enjoying the show. It didn't contain "American Horror Story" scare levels, but it was a great Sunday night soap with some fun psychological twists and a definite creep factor. Rachael Taylor was compelling and dynamic as Jane, and we're pretty bummed to move out of this twisted address come January.

-- Carina Adly MacKenzie, Zap2it