39 of 44
Sarah (Maiara Walsh)
We loved her because: You've got to respect a girl with the guts to toss around the freaking moonstone like a baseball. Of course, she didn't know it was the freaking moonstone, but still... you've also got to respect a girl with the good sense to have a crush on Jeremy.
We lost her because: Well, in order for Tyler to wolf out, someone had to die, and we're just glad it wasn't Matt. Katherine compelled Sarah to stab Tyler, who threw her off of him - right into his dad's desk, which conveniently, killed her. Adios, random.