10 p.m. ET Monday, Nov. 12
When we say you "must watch" this show, we mean it in the same way you "must watch" a train wreck if it happens right in front of you. Expanding (and improving) on the concept of the film of the same name, "Catfish" follows people as they meet their online friends (and lovers) face-to-face for the first time. The level of deceit and devastation in the pilot episode will haunt you -- and make you look a little closer at your Twitter pals' avatars. This isn't a gimmicky show about catching people in the act, though; it's about manufacturing and manipulating emotion in order to achieve one of two goals -- elation or heartbreak.
-- Carina Adly MacKenzie, Zap2it