58 of 63
'The Vampire Diaries' Season 5: Paul Wesley as Stefan/Silas
Seeing as how Silas locked Stefan in a safe and sunk it to the bottom of a lake at the end of Season 4, the Wesley we see in the beginning of Season 5 is actually Silas pretending to be Stefan ... got that? No word yet on when (we say when and not if, because we can't lose Stefan forever!) Stefan is saved/breaks free from his underwater prison ... but we hope it's soon.