11 of 66
Classification: Villain turned ... meh?
Brad was undoubtedly a villain after rejecting Jenni Croft and DeAnna Pappas the first time around. On his second chance, half the viewers seemed to adore him and Emily together, while half thought he made a huge mistake not choosing Chantal. Ultimately, his and Emily's breakup played out very publicly and while he didn't come across as a villain, he certainly hasn't evolved into a hero.