20 of 66
Classification: Villain turned hero
We didn't love David's bullying of Juan and his talk of "the man code" during Jillian's season, plus he got a little intense wanting Jillian to kiss him. But he came back to the "Bachelor Pad" house considerably more mellow, which let his humor and personality come through. We thought he was a fun co-winner for the first "Bachelor Pad" season.