49 of 66
Classification: Villain turned hero
Could they have found a better foil for the good women on Brad's second season? Michelle was self-centered, whiny and arrogant and it took all of 10 seconds before fans were calling for her ouster. However, she came on "Bachelor Pad" and totally redeemed herself, especially when she and Graham gamed the system during the Newlywed Game and made Vienna and Kasey have a complete meltdown.