The Best & Worst of 'One Tree Hill': 99 most memorable moments

(The CW)
20 of 100

John Doe as Mick Wolf

Episode: 604, "Bridge Over Troubled Water"

What: Peyton meets her biological father, Mick Wolf, for the first time.

Why: Peyton's bio-dad turns out to be a burned out rock star. How appropriate! Ultimately, he ends up disappointing her. This girl had four parents, and none of them really showed up for her.