30 of 100
Nathan had the ring all along
Episode: 318, "When It Isn't Like It Should Be"
What: During a harrowing senior year, Nathan and Haley finally get through their tough times... so Nathan steals her ring, and proposes to her all over again.
Why: Their first engagement and marriage was pretty rough, and after all they'd been through in their marriage and at school, it was nice to see Nathan and Haley step back and do things the right way, with a more mature perspective on their relationship.